Showing posts with label Opinions. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Opinions. Show all posts

Tuesday, 8 November 2011

Obsession

Behind the push for a reversion to cities designed for human beings and not machines are a variety of motivators.  While environmental and energy issues are often used to justify this neourbanism, as it is called, it is clear that there is some other driver.  Good livings are being made by good people as they prepare us for the long emergency that faces us as oil is depleted.  They trot out neourbanism as the main thing that is going to make the transition survivable while we reconfigure civilization to deal with a low energy future.

This is using a hammer to drive a screw: it will work, but not particularly well.  However, neourbanists persist with this single, possibly inappropriate, solution to a complicated problem because, I believe, they feel a perverse combination of schadenfreudeand masochism.

Imagine how they would feel if you were to say to them, “Hey, we’ve found a way to generate energy that is dramatically less expensive than anything we are using now, produces no carbon dioxide, can be used to destroy the fuel in atomic weapons, is safer than natural gas or coal and can provide all the energy we might need for the next few thousand years.”

I believe that they would feel pretty disappointed. The concrete justification they have for their obsession would vanish and they would be stuck in the mushy world of philosophy, trying to make convincing arguments that they are right.

The bad news, as I’ve learned far too late in my life, is that we have had just the technology I’ve described available to us since 1967... 1967!  And we’ve gone right ahead and put our world on a path to destruction that we may not be able to reverse.

Bad news for the neo-urbanists: governments are finally beginning to take note of this technology.  India is and has been for some time.  China is now moving forward on it.  Of course, the U.S. government which actually invented the technology, is ignoring it, but they’ll come around soon.  The question I want to ask is, what is the government of Singapore doing about this Liquid Florine Thorium Reactor (LFTR, pronounced “lifter”) technology?  Nothing that I can see.  Nothing that Wikileaks can see either.

The relaxed attitude of the government toward our dwindling energy supplies gives Singapore neo-urbanists a reprieve so they can still use Post-Peak doom and gloom to justify pushing their passion onto the world. But good and sufficient reasons exist outside of the disintegration of life as we know it to justify Neo-Urbanism:

“Modernist architecture is generally so bad that it is almost totally inappropriate for most common uses and climates.” Léon Krier

“A day spent without the sight or sound of beauty, the contemplation of mystery, or the search of truth or perfection is a poverty-stricken day; and a succession of such days is fatal to human life.”Lewis Mumford

“The chief function of the city is to convert power into form, energy into culture, dead matter into the living symbols of art, biological reproduction into social creativity.” Lewis Mumford

“There is a quality even meaner than outright ugliness or disorder, and this meaner quality is the dishonest mask of pretended order, achieved by ignoring or suppressing the real order that is struggling to exist and to be served. “Jane Jacobs

“The structure of life I have described in buildings - the structure which I believe to be objective - is deeply and inextricably connected with the human person, and with the innermost nature of human feeling.“Christopher Alexander

Being a practical sort of person, I suggest that you take a walk through any of the nicely conserved areas such as the one around Duxton Hill. and then walk around the perimeter of Suntec City.  Then decide which seems more suitable to your personal sense of self; which leaves you feeling like you've lived rather than simply persisted.  Singapore’s conserved areas aren’t perfect, but they do give a sense of what neo-urbanism is all about.  Suntec City, on the other hand, typifies everything that can go wrong when the human dimension is left out of the equation.  Neo-Urbanist Duxton Hill is for people.  Modernist Suntec City is for cars.

Which do you prefer?

Contributed by Frank Bouman

Read more...

Neo-Urbanism & the 3rd Industrial Revolution

The First Industrial Revolution was the introduction of coal and steam power to extend the power and speed of man.  It was characterised by a rapid centralisation of capital and political power amongst the new class of industrialists.

The Second Industrial Revolution took place with the introduction of petroleum and the internal combustion process managed through the aegis of the new era of telecommunications.

The Third Industrial Revolution is now rising with the accelerating shift to renewable energy and LFT reactors resulting in the distribution of the creation of information and electrical power creation medeiated by the Internet.

The five pillars of this Third Industrial Revolution are:

  1. shifting to renewable energy;
  2. transforming the building stock of every continent into micro-power plants to collect renewable energies on-site;
  3. deploying hydrogen and other storage technologies in every building and throughout the infrastructure to store intermittent energies;
  4. using Internet technology to transform the power grid of every continent into an energy-sharing intergrid that acts just like the Internet (when millions of buildings are generating a small amount of energy locally, on-site, they can sell surplus back to the grid and share electricity with their continental neighbors); and
  5. transitioning the transport fleet to electric plug-in and fuel cell vehicles that can buy and sell electricity on a smart, continental, interactive power grid. 1

Architects and planners have an important role to play even before we get to the first step: a shift to renewable energy. That role is in energy conservation.  Those best suited to the tasks are the neo-urbanists whose every action moves in the direction of energy conservation simply because of their application of the lessons taught by our grandfathers and grandmothers... well, mine, anyway.

The Congress for the New Urbanism says of the movement “New Urbanism is lighter on the pocketbook, more efficient with tax dollars, safer for pedestrians, bikers and drivers, easier on the environment and is a healthier way to live. It just performs better.”2

And that is exactly what the Third Industrial Revolution needs.

The densely populated urban areas of Asia present a particularly great challenge, and yet, when we look around the world we find many densely inhabited pockets within cities that are extremely livable because their construction preceded the flowering of the Second Industrial Revolution in the Fifties and Sixties when cities were still being made for humans and not for cars.

Unfortunately, the cities of Asia are by and large learning all the wrong lessons from what has gone before in the west, putting the automobile before people and manufacturing huge numbers of low-efficiency appliances just to keep the prices down, ignoring the high running cost, short lives and damage to the environment that results.

It is urgently necessary that governments learn that there is much more to be gained from the lessons gleaned from the past via the new urbanism than persisting in their pursuit of sterile modernist environments suitable only for machines.

One of the most conspicuous examples of the failure of governments to understand the needs of their societies is the hideous gargantuan triptych that destroys the cohesiveness of the otherwise salvageable public space around Marina Bay in Singapore. If it were visually interesting, that might have some redeeming value, but instead it looks like a cabin cruiser marooned on top of three giant gravestones as a result of a horrendous tsunami and is surrounded by pedestrian-hostile streets and motorways.  What could possibly have been going through the mind of anyone associated with giving this design the go ahead?  Certainly providing a livable environment for future generations wasn’t it.

This particular cloud’s silver lining is that it provides as splendid an example of architecture gone madly awry as one could want - and we get to see it every day as a reminder.


1  The Third Industrial Revolution: How Lateral Power is Transforming Energy, the Economy, and the World by Jeremy Rifkin,  Palgrave Macmillan 2011
2 http://www.cnu.org/

Next... Man vs. Machine

Contributed by Frank Bouman

Read more...

Man vs The Machine

In the years following WWII many commentators became extremely uncomfortable with the dehumanization of civilisation that was being brought about by hyper-industrialisation, uncontrollable science and technology, intrusive government and unresponsive politics.  All were faces of a die that, when cast, resulted in humanity’s loss and “the system’s” gains.  Perhaps the most famous critic of the direction that things were going was U.S. President Dwight Eisenhower who, when drafting is valedictory speech from the presidency, warned of the “congressional, military, industrial complex.” When he delivered the speech, he omitted Congress as one of the dangers, but in the event, his draft was correct.

What wasn’t apparent at the time was that the financial services industry would join this complex, take it over and turn it into a machine that could destroy not only humanity, but the planet.  Take it over, not in the sense that one leader deposes another, but in the sense that cancer cells, mindlessly following their programming, take over the body and eventually destroy it.  Cancer cells aren’t evil, they just go along with the system.

The machine’s excrement of soulless buildings and neighborhoods constrain the mind and wither the soul. Concrete and steel reach for the sky but curb reflection, displace nature and corrupt the meaning of progress.  It doesn’t have to be this way.

The machine proceeds on a path laid out by its DNA which is no more than the short-term self-interest of each of its components.  If any component becomes particularly successful, its self-interest will draw that of others into its sphere until its marginal utility to the machine is negligible and other components compete within the machine for temporary dominance in their respective spheres.  The critical point here is that the system is undirected and dominated by short-term thinking.

Short-term thinking doesn’t work very well.  Think of a complex maze.  It has an entry point and an exit point.  Traverse a maze in which you are immersed by trial and error.  If you make a wrong turn, you can turn around and go back.  Reality is full of decision points like a maze, but you can’t turn back; the only direction is forward. Light water nuclear reactors (LWR) became the global standard, not because they were the best technology but because they received more funding than thorium reactors (LFTR) at the earliest stages of nuclear power development.  The estimated ninety-three thousand people that have died in the wake of the Chernobyl LWR accident died simply because the machine can only move forward. We have known since 1967 that LFTR was far better technology than LWR, but now, forty-five years later, we have yet to build our first commercial LFTR plant.  Chernobyl began construction in 1970, three years after the advantages of LFTR became generally known but the machine just plowed on inexorably.

We make bad decisions, but not only do we make bad decisions, feedback is so slow that we are well beyond the point where we made that mistake and we’ve been compounding and re-compounding it before we realize what we’ve done.  Once we realize, we cannot go back, we can only change our direction going forward.  We have become machine in which we are enmeshed.

It doesn’t have to be that way.  Rarely an opportunity comes along where dramatic changes are possible and the machine can be reconstructed and redirected.  We have such an opportunity now.

Gross overpopulation, rapid depletion of our remaining resources, skyrocketing energy and food prices, an out-of-control financial system and a changing climate that every year exceeds the expectations of climate scientists in the speed and magnitude of its change have made it clear that we will either alter course or disappear as a species.

We need look no further than the cityscape that surrounds us to sense the corruption of the soul and the possibility of redemption within.

Next:  The dimensions of the crisis.

Contributed by Frank Bouman

Read more...

Tuesday, 18 October 2011

Urbanism and Environment

Whether they call themselves communist, capitalist or socialist, all of the Asian countries have embraced some variant of capitalism with the only real variation being who does the work and who gets the rewards.

Unfortunately, the "enlightened" developed countries aren't all that enlightened and the way each has dealt with urbanism and the environment is a product of their history and geography more than from any conscious decision to become this or that kind of a society.

Trying to transplant one set of solutions into another environment may or may not work. Clearly the "edifice complex" that characterizes much of Western architecture is no more sustainable in Asia than in the West.

An example of a transportation fix that can fail is the Bus Rapid Transit developed in Bogota. It worked miracles there and in a few other cities in the area. However, when applied to Mexico City it became a complete flop because the city fathers were reluctant to provide sufficient busses to make it work while the populace jammed on board the existing ones in far greater numbers than ever imagined. Meanwhile, the same system in Las Vegas is starving for lack of passengers.

What is probably needed is a combination of the best in neo-urbanist thought combined with the best in local thinking to develop something that will work in each country. Cookie-cutter approaches are doomed to failure.

Contributed by fgbouman

Read more...

Thursday, 13 October 2011

The Social Responsibility of Planning

Jiwa Studio calls attention to the social responsibilities faced by planners - consciously or unconsciously  - in the era of unprecedented economic growth in Asia.  

Urban Planning, Lifestyle, Natural Resources and the Environment

Read more...

Followers

Disclaimer

The contents on this site are provided as general information for educational purposes only and not meant to promote or discredit any of the projects discussed. The ideas expressed on this site are solely the opinions of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent the opinions of organizations or projects affiliated with the author(s). The author(s) may or may not have an affiliation in any project or organization referenced above.

  © Blogger templates The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP